Disaster coverage, in-depth reporting honored by CNHI
Published 4:00 pm Friday, March 15, 2019
MONTGOMERY, Ala. – Compelling coverage of a natural gas disaster that affected thousands of people in Massachusetts, the waste of tax dollars by antiquated townships in Indiana, and the dismissal of an admired college coach for misconduct in a small Iowa town highlighted distinguished journalism in the annual Best of CNHI contest for work in 2018.
The Eagle-Tribune of North Andover, Massachusetts, was named Newspaper of the Year in the Division I category for CNHI’s largest operations. The paper was cited principally for sustained and enterprising print and online coverage of a series of gas line explosions in three of its communities that killed one young man and forced the evacuation of 20,000 residents. Scores of local businesses, including the newspaper and many of its employees, were also affected. The devastation displaced more than 8,000 families for three months in the aftermath of the disaster while the gas lines into their homes and apartments were replaced. The paper helped hold the communities together throughout the recovery with stories about the human impact of the devastation and constant online updates on restoration of power and where to find shelter, food, water and other essentials.
The Eagle-Tribune also captured the Division I print and digital breaking news award for its swift and comprehensive reporting of the gas explosions on Sept. 13. and the immediate days of confusion that followed.
In Division II, the Gloucester Daily News in Massachusetts was named Newspaper of the Year. Judges praised its local coverage of news and feature stories and photos. The sports section won special praise for relevant content as did the local editorials. Overall, the paper was honored for a strong sense of the community it serves.
In Division III, the Gainesville, Texas, Daily Register captured Newspaper of the Year honors for fresh and frequently updated content online. Judges cited the paper for its hyper local coverage of the community, editorials that touched on subjects of interest to residents, lots of faces and names of local folks, and a solid sports section with good photos.
The Sharon, Pennsylvania, Herald earned the inaugural contest honor of 2018’s “Most Improved Newspaper” in the CNHI family of more than 100 papers. Judges praised the paper’s noteworthy progress in local news coverage and audience outreach in print and online under the direction of editor Renee Carey.
The Herald Bulletin of Anderson, Indiana, earned the top Public Service Award for Division I. It produced a series of multi-layered, in-depth stories — supported by helpful information graphics and editorials — on Indiana’s problematic township form of local government. The print and online project, which included contributions from the dozen other CNHI Indiana papers, scrutinized the contemporary value of townships, which date to the 18th century and have limited duties but cost Indiana taxpayers $389 million to maintain in 2018. The review found widespread problems with public access and engagement with township trustees, budget management issues and oversight controls. A statewide online poll commissioned by the project found 82 percent of those surveyed could not name their township trustee, and more than 70 percent thought township duties – helping the poor, providing fire protection in areas not covered by municipal fire departments, and maintaining pioneer cemeteries — should be shifted to another agency such as the county commission.
The Meridian, Mississippi, Star earned the Public Service Award among Division II newspapers for disclosing serious delays in the local justice system’s processing of criminal charges against jailed offenders. Accessing public records, reporter Whitney Downard created a database that disclosed most county jail inmates without means or with mental health issues end up waiting many months or more than a year before their cases are decided. In one instance, a defendant is still awaiting trial three years after his arrest in a murder case that goes back eight years. The contest judges praised the newspaper and reporter Downard for pursuing an ignored problem that affects disadvantaged individuals.
The Daily Iowegian of Centerville, Iowa, won the Public Service Award for Division III for revealing that a prominent baseball coach and his assistant coach were dismissed by the local community college for misconduct involving foreign players and for a pattern of physical and mental abuse of players. The college tried to keep the reasons for the dismissals secret but the paper’s pursuit of the story against the college’s stonewalling succeeded in reporting the news. The judges described it as great work in requesting records and developing sources to tell a complicated story.
West Virginia South, produced by the Beckley, West Virginia, Register-Herald, won Magazine of the Year honors in Division I for its attractive design, homey features, good use of color and exceptional scenic landscape photography. The judges said the magazine, from front cover to back page, created an exceptional sense of diverse local life in southern West Virginia.
Newburyport, a product of the Newburyport, Massachusetts, Daily News, took Division II honors in the magazine competition. Boomer magazine, produced by the Washington, Indiana, Times Herald, captured the top prize in Division III. Both were cited for their attractive design, good display of photos, and stories that reflected the character and interests of their respective communities.
Individual and digital category winners:
Reporter of the Year
Division I: Michelle James, Beckley, W. Va., Register-Herald
Division II: Whitney Downard, The Meridian, Miss., Star
Division III: Stan Polanski, Shelbyville, Ill., Union
Sports Writer of the Year
Division I: Clay Horning, Norman, Okla., Transcript
Division II: Elton Hayes, The Meridian, Miss., Star
Division III: Kyle Gaudette, Derry, N.H., News
Editorial Writer of the Year
Division I: Jim Zachary, Valdosta, Ga., Daily Times
Division II: Jeff Gerritt, Palestine, Tex., Herald-Press
Division III: Jeff Long, Shelbyville, Ill., Union
Columnist of the Year
Division I: Samantha Perry, Bluefield, W. Va., Daily Telegraph
Division II: Susan Duncan, Jeffersonville, Ind., News and Tribune
Division III: Todd Lancaster, Washington, Ind., Times Herald
Photographer of the Year
Division I: James Neiss, Niagara, N.Y., Gazette
Division II: Matt Hamilton, Dalton, Ga., Daily Citizen
Division III: Kyle Ocker, The Daily Iowegian, Centerville, Iowa
Breaking News Print-Digital Reporting of the Year
Division I: The Eagle-Tribune, North Andover, Mass.
Division II: Logansport, Ind., Pharos-Tribune
Division III: Gainesville, Tex., Daily Register
Designer of the Year
Division I: Heather Bremer, Anderson, Ind., Herald Bulletin
Division II: Kevin Burkett, Logansport, Ind., Pharos-Tribune
Division III: Amelia Tegerdine, Lebanon, Ind., Reporter
Social Media Use of the Year
Division I: Joplin, Mo., Globe
Division II: Jeffersonville, Ind., News and Tribune
Division III: Tahlequah, Okla., Daily Press
Digital Storytelling Innovation of the Year
Division I: Salem, Mass., News
Division II: Meridian, Miss., Star
Division III: Gainesville, Tex., Daily Register
Best Video of the Year
Division I: Beckley, W. Va., Register-Herald
Division II: Jeffersonville, Ind., News and Tribune
Division III: No winner